We spent ~$80 to buy 5 premium ChatGPT prompts and ran a blind take a look at among the many members of our advertising and marketing group to see in the event that they had been price it.
Lengthy story quick: They aren’t.
The experiment
Right here’s what I did:
- I signed up for a service promoting ChatGPT prompts and chosen 5 website positioning ones
- I created easy variations of those prompts (27 phrases on common, vs. 227 for the premium prompts)
- I entered these prompts into ChatGPT
- I took the output and did a blind ballot, asking the Ahrefs advertising and marketing group to guess which output was higher.
A complete of 15 individuals took the ballot.
Listed below are the outcomes:
The premium prompts solely convincingly “beat” the straightforward immediate for 2 duties.
Contemplating that you simply’ll have to cough up cash (in some instances, rather a lot) for these pre-engineered prompts, I’m skeptical they’re price it in any respect. I don’t assume you’re lacking out in case you don’t pay.
The anatomy of a “premium” immediate
Just about the entire “engineered” prompts we examined had the same construction.
I attempted to interrupt down what I noticed:
Particularly, listed below are the patterns:
- Function — Asks ChatGPT to behave as knowledgeable or professional with particular talent units.
- Goal language — Acts ChatGPT to reply in a specific language.
- Extremely-specific directions — Asks ChatGPT to do XYZ motion in excessive element.
- Emphasis on human-like writing — Asks ChatGPT to write down in a particular tone or fashion.
- Particular output — Asks ChatGPT to construction its response in a particular format, similar to markdown, tables, code bins, and many others.
The takeaway
This experiment is on no account educational nor scientific. It’s only a enjoyable, casual take a look at to see if “engineered” prompts might carry out higher than a easy command—at the very least in line with human interpretation.
Primarily based on the outcomes, although, I’m not satisfied that “premium” prompts actually try this a lot for you. It’s in all probability higher to begin off easy after which refine accordingly.
So, don’t waste your cash. Use it to improve to ChatGPT Plus as an alternative.
What do you assume? Let me know on Twitter X.